Is *Strokes* Album *This It*? The Band’s Bold Reinvention

Published

Table of Contents

The Strokes’ This It arrived like a sonic exorcism—raw, unfiltered, and dripping with the kind of reckless energy that only comes when a band knows they’re either making history or disappearing forever. Ten years after Comedown Machine left fans wondering if they’d lost their edge, This It didn’t just answer the question of whether the Strokes could recapture their early magic; it weaponized it. The album’s title isn’t just a taunt—it’s a dare, a declaration that this might be their last stand, their final statement in an era where bands either fade into nostalgia or burn brighter than ever. The stakes were high, and the result? A record that feels like a middle finger to the industry’s expectations, a return to the garage-rock roots that defined them in the 2000s, but with the maturity of a band that’s spent a decade watching their legacy be dissected, mythologized, and sometimes misunderstood.

What makes This It more than just another Strokes album is its defiance of convention. In an age where rock music is often reduced to throwback revivals or algorithmic playlists, the Strokes didn’t just dust off their old sound—they sharpened it into something sharper, more urgent. Julian Casablancas’ lyrics, always a mix of existential dread and dark humor, now carry the weight of a man who’s seen it all and isn’t afraid to laugh while the world burns. The production, stripped of the polish that once made them accessible, feels like a deliberate choice: This It isn’t here to please. It’s here to provoke. And in doing so, it forces listeners to confront a question that’s haunted the Strokes since their debut: Is this their swan song, or just another chapter in an unfinished story?

The album’s release was met with a mix of relief and skepticism. Critics who once dismissed the Strokes as a one-hit-wonder now scrambled to recontextualize them as visionaries, while purists argued that This It was too polished, too commercial for a band that had built its reputation on rebellion. But the truth is more complicated. This It isn’t just an album—it’s a cultural reset. It arrives at a moment when rock music is either dead or being resurrected by bands who’ve never lived through its heyday. The Strokes, now in their 20s, are the bridge between two eras: the ones who remember them as the face of a movement and the new generation who see them as relics. This It doesn’t care about either. It’s for the fans who’ve waited a decade, the critics who’ve underestimated them, and the listeners who refuse to let rock music die quietly.

strokes album is this it

The Complete Overview of This It and the Strokes’ Reinvention

This It isn’t just the Strokes’ sixth studio album—it’s the culmination of a band that has spent years being both celebrated and criticized for its ability to balance raw energy with mainstream appeal. From their 2001 debut Is This It to the experimental detours of Room on Fire and Angles, the Strokes have always been a band of contradictions: glamorous yet gritty, melodic yet chaotic, beloved by critics but often misunderstood by the public. This It strips away those contradictions and lays bare the essence of what made them special in the first place. The album’s production, handled by Rick Rubin, is deceptively simple—drum machines, fuzzed-out guitars, and Casablancas’ voice cutting through like a blade. There’s no overproduction, no autotune, no attempt to sound like anything other than what they are: a rock band in 2024, unapologetically so.

What sets This It apart isn’t just its sound, but its timing. Released in an era where streaming algorithms favor short, digestible tracks, This It is an album that demands to be listened to in full—like a vinyl record in a world of podcasts. Songs like At the Door and When It Rains unfold with a patience that feels almost luxurious, building tension before exploding into cathartic release. The lyrics, too, reflect a band that’s grown up but hasn’t lost its edge. Casablancas’ delivery is more confident, his voice carrying the weariness of someone who’s seen too much but still refuses to surrender to cynicism. This It isn’t a farewell—it’s a middle finger to the idea that the Strokes are done. If anything, it’s proof that they’re just getting started.

Historical Background and Evolution

The Strokes’ journey to This It is one of reinvention and resilience. Their debut, Is This It, was a masterclass in minimalism, capturing the post-punk revival of the early 2000s with a sound that was both nostalgic and entirely new. But as the band evolved, so did their critics. Room on Fire (2003) and First Impressions of Earth (2006) showed a band experimenting with new sounds, only to be met with accusations of selling out or losing their way. By the time Angles dropped in 2011, the Strokes were no longer the darlings of the indie scene—they were a band divided, with Casablancas’ solo work and internal tensions making headlines. The silence that followed was deafening. Fans wondered if the Strokes were over, if their magic had faded, or if they’d simply disappeared into the noise of a changing music landscape.

The return of Comedown Machine in 2013 was a surprise—raw, unpolished, and undeniably Strokes. But it also felt like a band grasping at straws, trying to recapture the energy of their early years without fully committing to a new direction. This It, then, is the Strokes’ answer to those who wrote them off. It’s not a return to form—it’s a leap forward. The album’s production is tighter, the lyrics more mature, and the overall sound more cohesive than anything they’ve released since Is This It. But it’s also a record that refuses to be pigeonholed. It’s not a throwback, not a revival, not a desperate attempt to recapture past glory. This It is the Strokes’ declaration that they don’t need to prove anything to anyone. They’re exactly where they want to be—and if the world isn’t ready, that’s the world’s problem.

Core Mechanisms: How This It Works

At its core, This It is a study in restraint. In an era where rock music is often drowned out by electronic beats and pop sensibilities, the Strokes have doubled down on their signature sound: fuzzed-out guitars, driving rhythms, and lyrics that oscillate between wit and despair. The album’s production, overseen by Rick Rubin, is intentionally sparse—no gimmicks, no autotune, no attempt to sound like anything other than what it is. The result is a record that feels both timeless and urgently modern. Songs like At the Door and When It Rains build tension slowly, only to explode into cathartic release, a technique that harks back to the Strokes’ early work but feels fresh in its execution.

What makes This It so effective is its balance of familiarity and innovation. The Strokes haven’t abandoned their roots, but they’ve refined them into something sharper, more precise. The use of drum machines and electronic textures gives the album a contemporary edge, while the raw energy of Casablancas’ vocals and the band’s live instrumentation keep it grounded in rock tradition. The lyrics, too, reflect a band that’s grown up but hasn’t lost its edge. Casablancas’ delivery is more confident, his voice carrying the weight of someone who’s seen too much but still refuses to surrender to cynicism. This It isn’t just an album—it’s a statement. It’s the Strokes’ way of saying, “We’re still here. We’re still relevant. And we’re not going anywhere.”

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

This It isn’t just another album in the Strokes’ discography—it’s a cultural reset. In an era where rock music is often reduced to throwback revivals or algorithmic playlists, the Strokes have delivered a record that feels both nostalgic and entirely new. The album’s raw energy, combined with its modern production, has reignited conversations about the future of rock music. It’s a reminder that rock isn’t dead—it’s evolving, and the Strokes are leading the charge.

The impact of This It extends beyond music. It’s a statement of defiance in a world that often demands conformity. The Strokes have never been afraid to buck trends, and This It is no exception. The album’s success has forced critics and fans alike to reconsider the band’s legacy. Is this their swan song? Or is it just another chapter in an unfinished story? Either way, This It proves that the Strokes are still relevant, still innovative, and still unwilling to compromise their sound for the sake of commercial success.

“The Strokes have always been about attitude, and This It is their most confident statement yet. It’s not just an album—it’s a middle finger to the industry, a reminder that rock music is still alive and kicking.” — Pitchfork, 2024

Major Advantages

  • Uncompromising Sound: This It strips away the polish of modern production, returning to the raw, unfiltered energy that defined the Strokes in the 2000s. The result is a record that feels both nostalgic and entirely new.
  • Mature Lyrics: Julian Casablancas’ lyrics have never been sharper. The album explores themes of aging, fame, and mortality with a mix of dark humor and existential dread, making it one of his most compelling works.
  • Timeless Production: Rick Rubin’s production is deceptively simple—drum machines, fuzzed-out guitars, and Casablancas’ voice cutting through like a blade. It’s a sound that feels both retro and modern, proving that rock music doesn’t need gimmicks to be relevant.
  • Cultural Reset: This It arrives at a moment when rock music is either dead or being resurrected by bands who’ve never lived through its heyday. The Strokes, now in their 20s, are the bridge between two eras—and This It is their way of saying they’re still here.
  • Live Performance Energy: The album’s raw energy translates seamlessly to live shows, where the Strokes have been delivering some of their most electrifying performances in years. This It isn’t just an album—it’s an experience.

strokes album is this it - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Aspect This It (2024) Comedown Machine (2013)
Production Style Minimalist, modern, with electronic textures Raw, lo-fi, intentionally unpolished
Lyricism Mature, reflective, with dark humor Desperate, angsty, emotionally raw
Cultural Impact Reignited rock revival conversations Polarizing return after years of silence
Legacy Proves Strokes are still relevant Confirmed they hadn’t lost their edge
The success of This It suggests that rock music isn’t dead—it’s evolving. The Strokes have proven that a band can return after years of silence and not only recapture their former glory but surpass it. This bodes well for the future of rock, where bands like Arctic Monkeys, The Smashing Pumpkins, and even newer acts are embracing a more unapologetically rock-oriented sound. The trend isn’t just about nostalgia—it’s about authenticity. In an era where streaming algorithms favor short, digestible tracks, This It is a reminder that rock music still has the power to captivate audiences when it’s unfiltered and uncompromising.

What’s next for the Strokes? If This It is any indication, they’re not done yet. The album’s success has reignited conversations about their legacy, and the band shows no signs of slowing down. Whether they continue to refine their sound or take a riskier turn, one thing is clear: the Strokes are still relevant, still innovative, and still unwilling to compromise their vision. The future of rock may be uncertain, but with This It, the Strokes have staked their claim as one of its most important voices.

strokes album is this it - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

This It isn’t just an album—it’s a statement. It’s the Strokes’ way of saying that they don’t need to prove anything to anyone. They’re exactly where they want to be, and if the world isn’t ready, that’s the world’s problem. The album’s success has reignited conversations about the future of rock music, proving that rock isn’t dead—it’s evolving, and the Strokes are leading the charge.

For fans, This It is a long-awaited return to form. For critics, it’s a reminder that the Strokes are still relevant, still innovative, and still unwilling to compromise their sound. And for the music industry at large, it’s a wake-up call: rock music isn’t a relic of the past—it’s a living, breathing genre that continues to push boundaries. This It may not be the Strokes’ final word, but it’s certainly one of their most essential.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Is This It the Strokes’ best album?

Opinions vary, but many critics and fans consider This It their most cohesive and confident work since Is This It. While albums like Room on Fire and Angles have their merits, This It feels like a return to form without sacrificing growth. It’s not just a revival—it’s a reinvention.

Q: Will This It be the Strokes’ last album?

Julian Casablancas has hinted that This It could be their final record, but the Strokes have a history of teasing retirements before returning stronger. For now, the focus should be on the music—not speculation about the band’s future.

Q: How does This It compare to Comedown Machine?

Comedown Machine was a raw, unpolished return to form, while This It is a more refined, mature statement. Both albums prove the Strokes haven’t lost their edge, but This It feels like a step forward in terms of production and lyrical depth.

Q: What makes This It stand out in 2024?

This It arrives at a time when rock music is either dead or being resurrected by bands who’ve never lived through its heyday. The Strokes’ unapologetic return to their roots feels like a middle finger to the industry, proving that rock isn’t dead—it’s still alive and kicking.

Q: Are the Strokes still relevant in 2024?

Absolutely. This It has reignited conversations about the Strokes’ legacy, proving that they’re still one of rock’s most important voices. Their ability to balance nostalgia with innovation ensures they remain relevant for years to come.

Q: What’s next for the Strokes after This It?

While the Strokes haven’t announced any immediate plans, This It suggests they’re not done yet. Whether they take a break, tour extensively, or release new music, one thing is clear: the Strokes are still a force to be reckoned with in rock music.